Last week we published our smartphone applications processor market share estimates for 2010. By our estimates, the smartphone applications processor market showed an impressive 77 year-over-year revenue growth in 2010 to reach $4.52 billion. Baseband-integrated applications processors accounted for 74 percent of total apps processor revenue in 2010 and we think it will remain relatively stable in the next few years.

Here are some highlights of our smartphone applications processor market share tracker 2010 report:

• Qualcomm led the smartphone applications processor market in 2010 with 41 percent revenue share on the strength of its strong participation in the multiple software ecosystems and its broad range of integrated processors. Qualcomm’s Snapdragon processors MSM8x50 and MSM7x30 gained good traction in the second half of 2010 and featured in multiple popular smartphones. We note that Qualcomm had over 50 percent revenue share lead over its nearest competitor Texas Instruments (TI). We believe that Qualcomm has a two-to-three year advantage over most of its competitors in terms of integration and is well positioned to move further ahead of its competitors with its upcoming MSM8960 LTE apps processor.

• TI ranked number two with 27 percent revenue share in 2010 despite topped the unit shipment rankings. TI’s stand-alone apps processor unit shipment share declined to 20 percent in 2010, by our estimates. We think TI's unit shipment leadership will be challenged by Qualcomm and Samsung in 2010.

• Samsung finished with 19 percent revenue share in 2010 and its unit shipments doubled on a year-over-year basis. Samsung's 1GHz Cortex-A8 Hummingbird apps processors featured in high-volume products such as Samsung Galaxy S, Wave and Wave II.

•  Marvell ranked number four in revenue terms but the company's over-dependency on a single customer is a cause for concern.

With over ten vendors already announced 1GHz dual-core Cortex-A9 processors, we expect 2011 to be highly competitive and ARM-based applications processor vendors should build competitive barriers by investing in graphics processing technologies, integration, micro architecture, multi-core processors, semiconductor process technologies and software expertise as the entry barrier is relatively low for new vendors to enter into the ARM-based ecosystem compared to the x86 chip ecosystem.

Client reading: Smartphone Apps Processor Market Share: Qualcomm’s Revenue Share Reached 41 Percent in 2010

Nokia announced today that it will adopt Microsoft's Windows Phone as its main strategy for smartphones, embracing Microsoft's developer ecosystem to drive its future smartphone growth. This is a significant announcement that changes the market dynamics dramatically and accelerates the horizontalisation in the mobile software platforms. Google's Android significantly contributed to the horizontalisation and now Nokia's partnership with Microsoft creates another credible choice. We have assessed Microsoft's mobile strategy back in March 2010 and it still holds true. We mentioned this Nokia partnership possibility in that report!

However, several questions remain like how Nokia will monetise its investments in MeeGo, Qt, Symbian, Ovi and Web Runtime and the availability of first Nokia Windows Phones. As for chipset vendors, last week we wrote that Qualcomm could be a prime beneficiary from this deal. We believe Nokia will add Qualcomm, Broadcom, ST-Ericsson, Renesas and Intel to its Windows Phone supplier list. We will know more on these questions as it unfolds today.

Texas Instruments (TI) gave a significant boost to its OMAP applications processor line-up yesterday by announcing the ARM Cortex A-15-based OMAP 5 applications processors, OMAP5430 and OMAP5432. The OMAP5432 is likely to target Microsoft's next generation Windows PC platform-based devices while the OMAP5430 is targeted at smartphones and tablets. The OMAP 5 applications processors, designed in 28 nm,  feature two ARM Cortex-A15 cores (each running at 2GHz) and also integrate Imagination Technologies' PowerVR SGX 544 graphics cores. ARM's Cortex-A15 can support up to eight cores and TI's OMAP 5 has only two cores suggesting that the software ecosystem is not yet ready for that many cores.

Most importantly, the new OMAP 5 applications processors bring two new features including graphics computing and hardware virtualization that are currently not available in the current generation processors. Graphics computing APIs such as OpenCL facilitate GPU computing by enabling GPU access to non-graphics applications. ARM's next generation graphics core Mali T-604 also offers support for graphics computing APIs such as OpenCL.

The mobile industry is in the midst of figuring out killer apps for graphics computing. Apple is a big proponent of OpenCL and is expected to bring it to its future iOS devices which could act as a positive catalyst for OpenCL's  take-off on mobile devices. Features such as hardware virtualization can help enhance security and also preserve the legacy application ecosystem. This could be an important feature for Microsoft as they transition to a new application framework in their next generation Windows platform for SoCs.

As we mentioned on this blog previously, TI is currently facing headwinds in the smartphone market from the baseband-integrated vendors such as Qualcomm. We see the integration trend to continue in smartphones as OEMs demand more and more integration to reduce their BoM costs which could put TI's OMAP processors at a disadvantage, particularly in the low-to-mid range smartphone category. However, Microsoft's upcoming next generation Windows platform for SoCs could create another opportunity for TI to revitalize its OMAP business.

Most recently, TI announced a BlackBerry PlayBook tablet design-win at RIM but hasn't yet announced a smartphone design-win for its OMAP 4 applications processor which is bit of a concern as Qualcomm and ST-Ericsson's baseband-integrated dual-core processors come into the market. Qualcomm's MSM8x60 and ST-Ericsson's U8500 / U5500 products integrate an HSPA+ baseband modem and dual ARM Cortex-A9 cores (or equivalent) which puts them on a par with NVIDIA's Tegra2 and TI's OMAP 4 applications processors. The OMAP 5-based are expected to appear in products in late 2012 but until then TI has to defend itself from the baseband-integrated vendors.

Other publicly announced ARM Cortex-A15 licensees include NVIDIA, Samsung and ST-Ericsson and TI will probably face competing products from these companies in future.   We note that Qualcomm's next generation Snapdragon processors MSM8960 and MSM8270 are also designed in 28 nm and integrate dual Cortex-A15 equivalent processing cores. The MSM8960 also integrates multi-mode LTE baseband modem, Adreno GPU and a variety of connectivity functionality (GPS, WLAN, Bluetooth and FM). TI has to fight highly integrated products like these in future and we are cautiously optimistic about OMAP 5 given the trend towards integration. However, the market is expanding rapidly and an assortment of mobile devices are coming to the market with a variety of operating systems which could be a positive thing for TI.  

Multi-core processors are the name of the game in high-end smartphones and tablets in 2011 and are increasingly becoming an essential marketing and technology strategy for every handset vendor and silicon vendor. We estimate multi-core processor penetration in smartphones will rise from 15 percent in 2011 to 45 percent in 2015, and that ARM's Cortex-A9, Cortex-A5 and Cortex-A15 and Intel's x86 architectures will fuel the multi-core processor growth in smartphones over the next few years. 

In 2010, over 45 percent of Android smartphones shipped with a 1GHz or higher processor, hitting the ceiling on what is possible with a single core processor. Adding a second core is the logical next step to boosting the speed without raising the power consumption in handheld devices such as smartphones.

Samsung, Qualcomm, NVIDIA, ST-Ericsson, Texas Instruments, Marvell, Renesas and Broadcom are well positioned to capture share in the smartphone multi-core processor market. Freescale recently announced its i.MX 6 processor family but the company has less visibility when it comes to smartphone design-wins.

Having largely won the single core smartphone apps processor market, baseband-integrated vendors are now faced with a multi-core processor challenge. We believe the smartphone multi-core processor market will be dominated by stand-alone apps processor vendors in 2011. By our estimates, baseband-integrated multi-core apps processor will account for about one third of total smartphone multi-core apps processor shipments in 2011 with the potential for higher share in future.

Sravan Kundojjala

Microsoft announced at CES-2011 that its next generation Windows PC platform will run on ARM architectures. NVIDIA, Qualcomm and Texas Instruments were named as key ARM silicon partners. We think this is good news for stand-alone ARM applications processor vendors such as Texas Instruments (TI) and throws the company a lifeline at a time when the market is moving towards integrated solutions.

By our estimates, the market for stand-alone applications processors in smartphones contracted from 70 percent in 2007 to just under 30 percent in 2009. Vendors such as Qualcomm are driving the baseband-integrated applications processor market and these integrated processors are increasingly gaining acceptance in the smartphone market. The integrated approach is currently popular in the low-to-mid range smartphones but is gaining traction in the high-end as well lately.

Microsoft's decision to port the Windows PC platform to ARM architectures changes the market dynamics dramatically. However, it's too early to tell what impact it will have on Intel as Microsoft hasn't revealed any timeline for these new products. ARM hasn't yet revealed its 64-bit architecture and current generation ARM processors also cannot support graphics computing APIs such as OpenCL. It will take at least another 18-24 months for Microsoft to reengineer its platform for ARM architectures and to build a software ecosystem around it. This should give enough time for Intel to bring power-efficient processors to the market. Intel is expected to feature in Nokia's MeeGo smartphones and tablets in 2012 which we think would be a great psychological boost to counter ARM-based processor vendors.

The likely specs for Windows on ARM architectures are:

• CPU: Dual-core / Quad-core ARM Cortex-A9; GPU: ARM Mali-400 / Third-party GPU

• CPU: Multi-core ARM Cortex-A15; GPU: ARM Mali T-604 / Third-party GPU (Most likely configuration and leading chip vendors such as TI, NVIDIA and Samsung were already announced as licensees of Cortex-A15 cores)

• Custom ARM processor designed by Microsoft and its hardware partners

This move is a good news for NVIDIA, Qualcomm and TI as it opens up new opportunities. Qualcomm already has customer relationships with top PC vendors and is expected to leverage them to expand into the Windows PC ecosystem. This move equally helps the stand-alone applications processor vendors to revitalize their businesses and to compete for higher volume. Broadcom, ST-Ericsson, Samsung, Renesas, Marvell and Freescale could also potentially feature as future Microsoft's partners.

We believe diversified device and OS landscape favors chip vendors as they can avoid the risk of being sidelined by powerful vendors. With Microsoft's support, ARM chipset vendors can now look forward to new markets that were unavailable to them previously.

Mobile phone applications processors power today's smartphone apps and increasingly phones are promoted as packing "1GHz processors" or even "dual-cores".

Last week we published our smartphone applications processor market share data and by our estimates global applications processor revenue reached $1.84 billion in 1H 2010, up 60 percent over the same period the prior year, primarily thanks to the growth in smartphones. The increase in the smartphone market is real and it has been reflected in silicon vendors' revenues and shipments as many players are re-positioning themselves to tap into this growth. The battle between the baseband-integrated applications processor vendors and stand-alone applications processor vendors continues to fragment the market.

Here are some top-level insights from our quarterly smartphone applications processor market share tracker for 1H 2010:

• In just three years, the market for stand-alone apps processors has shrunk from around 72 percent of the total apps processor market to just 32 percent in unit terms in 1H 2010.

• Qualcomm led the overall smartphone applications processor market with 35 percent revenue share, thanks to its early-mover advantage in the Android ecosystem. Qualcomm's integrated applications processors, which combine advanced air interface technology and applications processing capability, are increasingly gaining acceptance in the smartphone market. Qualcomm's smartphone applications processor unit shipment share increased from just 3 percent in 2007 to 19 percent in 1H 2010.

• Texas Instruments (TI) led the market in unit terms with the help of its legacy Nokia relationship. TI ranked number two in the stand-alone applications processor category with 24 percent revenue share. We believe much of the TI's future growth depends on the traction for its OMAP4 series applications processors and it may prove difficult for the company if it fails to line up big customers for its OMAP4 series processors in 2011.

• Samsung's relationships with Apple and Samsung helped the company to reach number one in stand-alone category and number three overall in the smartphone apps processor market in revenue terms. Samsung is set to continue its momentum into 2011 with the help of Apple and Samsung.

• Marvell ranked number four in both revenue terms and unit shipment terms on the strength of its relationship with RIM. Marvell's ARMADA 618 / 628 high-performance processors are expected to be adopted by RIM for its smartphone and tablet products in 2011.

• Qualcomm, Texas Instruments, Samsung, Marvell, Renesas and ST-Ericsson together accounted for 98 percent of total smartphone applications processor unit shipments in 1H 2010.

Looking forward, we expect new players such as NVIDIA, Intel, Broadcom and MediaTek to attack the high-growth smartphone market with focused efforts in 2011. We also expect the stand-alone applications processor vendors to fight back with high-performance dual-core processors in 2011 which could potentially increase their value share in 2011.

- Sravan Kundojjala

Broadcom announced today that it will acquire privately held 4G chipset vendor Beceem Communications for $316 million. Beceem, founded in 2003, is the leading provider of WiMAX basebands and RF chips for portable and handheld WiMAX devices. The company also supplies WiMAX radio chipsets for gateways, routers and other fixed WiMAX customer premise equipment. Recently Beceem started to shift its emphasis to LTE with the announcement of its BCSM500 baseband, which will support both LTE and WiMAX. Broadcom so far hasn't announced its LTE plans publicly, and this acquisition signals that the company is looking to the future in the wake of growing competition and consolidation in the cellular baseband supplier base. Broadcom acquired GSM/GPRS/EDGE and W-CDMA technology through acquisitions, and these are now paying off, so it appears that Broadcom is repeating this strategy for LTE.

Beceem supplies basebands for all of the WiMAX USB dongles and data cards sold by Clearwire, the largest WiMAX operators in terms of subscribers. Beceem generated $43.7 million in revenue in 2009 with net loss of $17 million, but with shipments surpassing 1 million chips per quarter in Q3 '09 and sales having tripled since 2008, the company appeared headed for profitability by late 2010. Buoyed by this success, Beceem filed for an IPO initially thought to be worth more than $100 million in April '10. This would have made a nice down-payment to investors, which include Intel Capital, DoCoMo Capital, Samsung Venture Investment and NEC. Investment by all VCs in Beceem totals close to $200 million to date.

By August 2010, announcements of support for LTE by operators around the world made it clear that Beceem faced a weakening, or at best slower growth WiMAX market, cutting the value of its proposed IPO. With its new LTE-WiMAX baseband, Beceem could benefit from the launch of LTE by Verizon Wireless, AT&T Mobility, and MetroPCS in North America, however, Beceem will not ship samples of its WiMAX-LTE baseband before Q1 ’11. After shipping its first samples and getting them designed into products, Beceem would still have to go through interoperability testing (IOT) with infrastructure vendors and demonstrate support for FDD and TDD in multiple channel bandwidths. The IOT process could take 18 months or longer, pushing LTE chip production out to mid-2012 or later for Beceem. In light of this, investors evidently saw risks in continuing to support Beceem, and decided to take Broadcom’s offer.

From Broadcom's perspective, the acquisition will allow Broadcom to offer home gateway / router platforms that incorporate 4G, Wi-Fi, cable, DSL and / or fiber optics, which would allow multiple users in a household to share a single wired or wireless broadband connection, cutting the monthly price per user. Of even more potential significance, the acquisition will allow Broadcom to eventually expand into LTE mobile devices. Until then, Broadcom can draw on Beceem’s success in WiMAX USB dongles, PC data cards and handsets to help fund development of LTE chipsets.

It seems likely that merchant baseband suppliers Qualcomm, ST-Ericsson, Altair Semi, Icera, Renesas and Intel / Infineon will beat Broadcom to market in LTE, particularly in the rapidly growing “non-handset” (our term) segment of the mobile market consisting of USB dongles, PC data cards, M2M modules and related data-centric wireless modem devices. By our estimates, basebands for the non-handset mobile market accounted for about 12 percent of the total baseband market in revenue terms in 1H 2010. Currently Qualcomm, Icera, Infineon and ST-Ericsson have the leading market share in basebands for non-handsets, a market today dominated by 3G. An increasing proportion of future non-handset WWAN data modems will support LTE plus 3G, making LTE capability essential for firms to continue supplying basebands into this important segment. Note that compared to LTE + 3G, it appears that LTE + WiMAX mobile devices will at best represent a small niche market.

When Broadcom enters the LTE baseband market, we expect the company to offer chipsets with comprehensive support for legacy GSM air interfaces through W-CDMA / HSPA+, multi-mode / multi-band RF transceivers, plus optional Wi-Fi / Bluetooth / GPS, and optional ancillary chips for mobile TV and advanced video processing. Broadcom had only about 3.3 percent share of the cellular baseband market in unit terms in 1H 2010, but the company's market share in basebands is growing rapidly with design wins at top-tier OEMs.

Broadcom's acquisition of Beceem leaves other baseband start-ups Icera, Altair Semiconductor, Sequans and Wavesat as potential acquisition targets for established baseband / chipset vendors looking to expand into LTE. Of these start-ups, Altair Semiconductor, which sampled its first LTE baseband in September ’09, appears to be in the lead with LTE basebands now reaching early production status. Another firm to watch in LTE is Intel, which recently acquired WiMAX / LTE chipset start-up Comsys and announced its intention to acquire the cellular chipset product lines of Infineon. Intel Capital has a 20 percent stake in Beceem, so we can only speculate that Intel decided that acquiring Comsys and Infineon would offer better synergies and returns on investment given that Intel already ships WiMAX chipsets into the embedded laptop market.

Aside from LTE chipsets, Broadcom also has to solve is its smartphone applications processor challenges; by our estimates, Broadcom had no share in smartphone applications processors in 1H 2010. Broadcom scored design-wins in Nokia's Symbian^3 smartphones recently with its BCM2727 co-processor, but we believe that Broadcom has to integrate BCM2727 functionality into its basebands to score significant smartphone design-wins in the future.

Last week we published our cellular baseband market share estimates for 1H 2010. By our estimates, cellular baseband unit shipments grew 23 percent and revenues grew 15.5 percent from 1H 2009 to 1H 2010. The non-handset segment, which includes PC data cards, PNDs, netbooks, tablets wireless USB dongles and M2M, accounted for 12 percent of total baseband revenues in 1H 2010 and grew faster than the handset baseband market.

Here are some highlights of our cellular baseband market share estimates:

• Qualcomm continued its revenue share lead with 39.6 percent share in 1H 2010. Qualcomm ranked number one in CDMA and W-CDMA baseband markets. We believe much of the Qualcomm's growth came from smartphones and non-handsets in 1H 2010.

• MediaTek ranked number two in revenue share behind Qualcomm with 16.3 percent share in 1H 2010. Contrary to popular perception, MediaTek currently doesn't compete head-to-head with Qualcomm and only recently launched its first W-CDMA baseband. By our estimates MediaTek had less than 1 percent W-CDMA share in 1H 2010 but the company ranked number one in GSM/GPRS/EDGE (GGE) and TD-SCDMA baseband markets in revenue terms. MediaTek’s baseband shipments to grey handset OEMs showed signs of decline in 1H 2010 in the wake of government-led crackdowns in India and China.

• ST-Ericsson finally showed signs of recovery in 1H 2010 after a difficult 2009 with its improved and rationalized product line up for GGE, TD-SCDMA, W-CDMA and LTE markets. However, the company has to shift its focus to its stagnant W-CDMA market share to compete against Qualcomm and Infineon.

• Infineon continued to gain share in GGE and W-CDMA markets with the help of its top-tier handset OEM relationships. By our estimates Infineon is emerging as a strong competitor to Qualcomm in the non-handset market also with 9 percent unit shipment share in the non-handset segment of the W-CDMA market. Infineon is expected to improve its non-handset baseband share further once Intel completes its acquisition in 2011. Texas Instruments' exit from the baseband market creating opportunities for Infineon and Broadcom at Nokia.

• Broadcom's baseband revenue grew 245 percent in 1H 2010 compared to same period the year before thanks to its design-wins at Nokia and Samsung. By our estimates W-CDMA revenues accounted for 17 percent of Broadcom's total baseband revenues in 1H 2010 and the company continued to improve its product-mix.

• Spreadtrum, Marvell, Icera, and Via Telecom also made progress in 1H 2010. Renesas' baseband revenues were down slightly but the company is expected to emerge as strong player by 2012 with LTE chipset design-wins at Nokia.

Looking forward, we believe that the non-handset market and new radio technologies (HSPA+, LTE and TD-SCDMA) to create growth opportunities for baseband vendors.

Consolidation in the baseband market continued with Intel acquiring Infineon's wireless business on Monday for $1.4 billion. Infineon's takeover is the fourth high-profile announcement in the last two years. Previously NXP, Freescale and Texas Instruments announced their exits from the merchant baseband market. This signals that the entry barrier is now too high for new entrants and raises pressure on smaller players such as Marvell, Spreadtrum and Icera. Intel's acquisition of Infineon's wireless business leaves Qualcomm, MediaTek, ST-Ericsson, Intel, Broadcom and Renesas as long-term players in the cellular baseband market.

We analyzed this back in May when the original rumour of the Intel/Infineon wireless deal surfaced. Infineon's wireless business is definitely an attractive target for Intel as it gives immediate access to valuable IP and an established customer base. Infineon is a rising star in the W-CDMA baseband market and ranked number two in the W-CDMA baseband market behind Qualcomm (excluding Texas Instruments’ custom baseband business with Nokia). Infineon has so far focused on slim modems and has stayed away from developing ARM-based applications processors. So far Infineon’s niche strategy has paid off, but the time has come for the company to expand its portfolio by offering a wider range of processors to address smartphones, tablets and other connected consumer devices. Although 3G and smartphones are of most interest to Intel, the company is likely to keep Infineon’s 2G business as it provides scale which is crucial to play in the cellular baseband segment.

It will be another year or two before Intel's applications processors are smartphone-ready. Meanwhile, in the next 12 - 18 months Intel can bundle Infineon's 3G platform with all of its notebook and netbook chipsets and gain significant 3G share to undercut Qualcomm and ST-Ericsson's non-handset offerings. But both Qualcomm and ST-Ericsson appear to have a two year technology lead over Infineon in chipsets for HSPA+ and LTE; Infineon is expected to introduce its first HSPA+ chipset in 2011 and an LTE chipset in 2012. MediaTek’s grey handset chip business may come under pressure from Infineon in the future if Intel expands its field application engineering force in China. Likewise, Broadcom is expected to come under pressure from this deal but should survive with help from its other businesses such as connectivity and digital home. This acquisition will also likely affect stand-alone application processor vendors such as Texas Instruments and NVIDIA that currently lack their own 3G / 4G modems. But we believe that it will take another 4-5 years for Intel to integrate basebands into its Atom CPU, if at all.

Infineon's acquisition still doesn’t guarantee Intel's success in the wireless handset market and the company's ultimate success in this market hinges on how soon Intel can come up with power-efficient processors that can stand-up and compete against a host of ARM-based processor vendors. On a positive note, Intel appears to be moving ahead of its other chip competitors in the software area which positions it well against ARM-based processor vendors. The company’s strong software expertise could help it to gain some OEM mindshare. Intel’s uninspiring track record in the wireless market during the last decade suggests that the company has to execute flawlessly this time to make it successful and keep Infineon’s wireless business as independent as possible. Clients can read our eight page analysis of the Intel/Infineon deal here.

As smartphone shipments grow as a percentage of total mobile phone shipments, processor suppliers also have to revise their strategies to tap into this growth. Who is well-positioned? We think baseband vendors are well positioned to capture this growth given their leverage to work their existing OEM relations. To make the transition from the featurephone world to the smartphone world, processor vendors have to develop application processors and multimedia processors in addition to cellular baseband processors.

The game is no longer about slim modems. Based on our research many of the leading baseband vendors are missing the growth opportunities in the smartphone segment. Estimates in our recent report entitled “Can Baseband Vendors Translate Their Success into the Smartphone Market?” reveal that the cumulative smartphone apps processor unit shipment share of Qualcomm, ST-Ericsson, MediaTek, Infineon and Broadcom was just 21 % in 2009 despite their cumulative overall baseband unit shipment share of about 65%. What this means is that baseband vendors have not been too successful in converting their baseband design-wins into apps processor design-wins so far.

A chip vendor's success in the smartphone world comes from scoring design-wins at top-tier smartphone OEMs and supporting software platforms that have market momentum. This is one of the reasons why baseband vendors missed the smartphone boat as many of them were focusing on feature phone and basic phone segments. We think there is enough room for dynamism in the smartphone processor market as new entrants like Intel come into the value chain. If Intel acquires Infineon, as rumoured, that could put more pressure on stand-alone processor vendors, such as NVIDIA, that currently lack baseband products. Interesting times ahead. We’ll be watching how baseband vendors expand their value offering to crack the smartphone and other emerging devices markets.